12-08-15 MinutesYELM CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
TUESDAY, DECEMBERS, 2015 MINUTES
1. Mayor Harding called the meeting to order at 6:00 pm.
2. Roll Call Present: JW Foster, Joe Baker, Bob Isom, Tad Stillwell, Tracey Wood,
Ken Garmann and Russ Hendrickson.
Agenda Approval
15-107 MOTION BY RUSS HENDRICKSON APPROVING THE AGENDA AS
PRESENTED. CARRIED.
4. Special Presentations -
November Student of the Month -
Sarah McAuley is an amazing young adult at Yelm High School. Academically she
is talented and near the top of her class, combining both YHS and Running Start
workloads. As a leader Sarah is highly active in a variety of programs including
cheerleading, chamber choir and leadership summit. Sarah also volunteered to
plan and put on the highly successful sophomore orientation'. It is also quite
common that Sarah spends time at school helping teachers. After, graduation,
Sarah plans to pursue an ROTC program at a 4 -year college, and is currently
leaning toward Central Washington University. Sarah is a great ambassador for
Yelm High School. Mayor Harding presented Ms. McAuley with a plaque and
thanked for attending the meeting.
5. Public Comment - no public comment
6. Consent Agenda
Minutes - Regular Meeting November 24, 2015
Payables - Checks #65823 - #65936, Totaling $689,669.33
15-108 MOTION BY RUSS HENDRICKSON APPROVING THE CONSENT AGENDA AS
PRESENTED. CARRIED.
7. Public Hearing -
a. Continued Public Hearing from November 24, 2015
Ordinance No. 1008 - 2016 City of Yelm Budget
Mayor Harding continued the Public Hearing at 6:07 from November 24, 2015.
Noah Crocker presented a slide show on the updated figures for the budget. There
were only minor changes from the preliminary budget presented on November 24.
Tami Merriman presented the Mayor and Council with a letter regarding the
proposed 2016 Budget as part of the official record. All non -represented, non-
exempt employees were present during the public hearing comment with the
exception of Dana Spivey. On August 24, 2015, the non -represented, non-exempt
employees filed a petition to form a union under the Washington State Council of
County and City Employees (WSCCCE). In March 2015, the collective bargaining
agreement between Teamsters Local Union No. 252 and the City of Yelm was
ratified. The contract included a 2.25% COLA increase in 2015 and 2016, as well
as a change in medical benefits that the City would pay 95% of the employee's
health insurance premiums, and the employee would pay the other 5%. Non -
represented employees received with their April 2015 pay stubs, notice of the
amended salary scale to include the 2.25% COLA and the increased cost of health
insurance pursuant to the Public Works contract. On November 20, 2015 non -
represented employees received an email that stated "because the WSCCCE
12/8/15
bargaining is pending, and the cost of living (COLA) is part of the bargaining
process, the wage scale for this membership was unchanged from 2015, with the
exception of step increases." The non -represented employees continue to pay the
5% insurance premium. According to the National Labor Relations Act, the work
place environment must stay "status quo" until a contract is ratified. It appears
that withholding an approved and expected wage increase while still requiring a
percentage of health insurance premiums is a change to the non -represented
employee's work place environment. Mayor Harding stated the situation is similar
to when the Police Department switched from the Teamsters Union to the Police
Guild. The Cost of Living (COLA) is a negotiated item therefore it is not
automatically carried over to 2016. Mayor has been in contact with the City's
Union negotiation representative and this is the direction he advised the City to
take. Councilmember Wood said the council needs clarification on where we are in
the process. He does not believe that everyone on the Council is aware of this
issue and what our legal input has been. Councilmember Stillwell asked if the
employees are currently paying the 5% of the premium and not receiving the
COLA. Mayor Harding stated the City is maintaining the medical benefit at the
existing level. Janine Schnepf, City Clerk/HR Manager stated that in the past, the
COLA had been applied based on the other union negotiations. Prior to this year,
there was not the third union. This year is unique in that the new unit was just
formed so a piece of the new bargaining will be that salary piece and that is why it
is not applied in 2016. Councilmember Foster clarified that the unrepresented
employees will not be receiving the COLA for the start of 2016, but will negotiate
a COLA in their new contract when the negotiations take place. The Mayor stated
that when a new union is formed, there is no pursuing benefit as far as COLA's.
That is a bargained benefit. Councilmember Stillwell asked if the health care is a
bargained benefit as well. Mayor Harding stated they could bargain the health
care as part of the negotiation process. Mayor Harding is hesitant to make any
changes and is unsure if it is even appropriate for the council to engage with the
employee's one on one when they have a collective bargaining unit.
Councilmember Isom stated that both of the items mentioned are negotiable
items in a contract. This particular group of employees has never had a contract,
(in his opinion) therefore any provisions or benefits of other contracts were given
to the non -represented employees was done out of fairness. Councilmember Isom
is personally uncomfortable with this entire conversation because they are
represented at this stage of the game. Councilmember Garmann asked about the
timeline of the bargaining and the COLA. Mayor Harding stated Councilmember
Isom's comment sums it up. Mayor Harding hopes the bargaining will start quickly
and this will be a mute point. Tami Merriman stated that the union representative
for the non- represented employees was not aware of the change in COLA's until
it was brought to his attention by City Staff, and it was a shock and
disappointment to receive the email in November. Councilmember Garmann
stated that to have this come to the attention of Council at the last minute of the
budget process, seems like it should be examined more thoroughly and have
more discussion, like the Police Guild got a sign on bonus to make up for the lack
of COLA increase, if staff was promised this increase and it is being denied due to
timing, it does not seem fair. It does not seem right that we as a Council have not
had the opportunity to have discussion. Mayor Harding stated that it would have
been much more appropriate if the union agent would have contacted, the City's
representative and talked about this in advance. Councilmember Foster asked
Noah if the 2016 budget number reflected the 2.25% COLA for the non -
represented employees. Noah stated that the 2016 budget does not include a
12/8/15
2016 COLA for non -represented employees. Mayor Harding closed the public
hearing at 6:31.
8. New Business —
a. Ordinance No. 1008, 2016 City of Yelm Budget
Noah Crocker, Finance Director stated that Mayor Harding and staff present a
balanced 2016 Budget. The current budget has changed very little since it was
last presented. The expenses have been brought up to date. The $6.867 million
dollar general fund reflects a conservative approach to revenue projections
($5.071 million), as well as a thorough analysis of planned expenditures. It
maintains current programs, contracts and levels of service provided to the
community. The Interfund Loans for $245,000 from the General Fund to Fund
316 have change since we received a portion of the grant money since the last
meeting. The Interfund Loan has been reduced by $177,000. Noah thanked the
Mayor and Administrative staff in helping developing the budget. Councilmember
Isom moved to approve Ordinance No. 1008. Seconded by Councilmember Wood.
Mayor Harding asked for further discussion. Councilmember Garmann stated
because his term is ending he will be abstaining from the voting on the budget.
Councilmember Stillwell will also abstain since this is only the second Council
meeting he has attended. Councilmember Baker stated this is his last meeting
and he will abstain from voting. Mayor Harding informed the Council that if they
did not have an operating budget at the end of this meeting, no staff could come
to work. Councilmember Foster felt that process of adopting and working through
this budget was a fair representation of what we had negotiated and achieved
throughout the year with our revenues and expenditures. Councilmember Foster
believes that next year's budget will also show that we are being efficient and
responsible with the funds for the City of Yelm. Mayor Harding called for the
question.
15-109 MOTION BY BOB ISOM ADOPTING ORDINANCE NO. 1008, 2016 CITY OF
YELM BUDGET. 4 -AYES (FOSTER, ISOM, WOOD AND HENDRICKSON), 3 -
ABSTAINED (BAKER, STILLWELL AND GARMANN). MOTION CARRIED.
b. Nisqually River Foundation — Intergovernmental Services Contract for
2016
Noah Crocker, Finance Director reported that the Nisqually River Foundation,
(formerly known as the "Yelm Community Schools-Nisqually River Education
Project", now recognized as a 501C3 not-for-profit organization associated with
the Nisqually River Council), seeks to create a new generation of Yelm citizens
who are aware of and care for Yelm Creek, the Nisqually River and the City of
Yelm's water resources, including groundwater, surface water, wastewater and
reclaimed water. If approved, this will be the City of Yelm's 13th year supporting
this cause. Through this support, the City of Yelm will join other local
governments in supporting this outstanding watershed education program and
will be recognized as a Nisqually River Foundation and Congress sponsor. A
request for continued support was received on November 16, 2015 in the amount
of $3,500.00.
15-110 MOTION BY BOB ISOM TO APPROVE AND AUTHORIZE MAYOR HARDING
TO SIGN THE ATTACHED INTERGOVERNMENTAL SERVICES CONTRACT
FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY 1, 2016 — DECEMBER 31, 2016 IN THE
AMOUNT OF $3,500.00, BETWEEN THE CITY OF YELM AND THE
NISQUALLY RIVER FOUNDATION — NRF". CARRIED.
12/8/15
c. YELM MULTIPURPOSE SENIOR CENTER CONTRACT
Noah Crocker, Finance Director stated that the Washington State Constitution
allows the city to provide funding to non-profit organizations for the necessary
support of the poor and infirm. Historically, the City of Yelm has contributed
monthly funding to the Yelm Adult Community Center (Senior Center) to aid in
their mission of providing services to the senior community. The amount
approved by Council in 2014 is $1,000.00 per month. The City Council has
indicated they would like to continue to provide these services funds to the Yelm
senior multi-purpose center and staff recommends approval of a contract
extension from May 2015 -December 2016. Councilmember Wood asked what the
previous monthly amount was, and if it was increasing to $1,000. Noah stated it
had been $500 a month.
15-111 MOTION BY BOB ISOM APPROVING RESOLUTION NO. 562 ESTABLISHING
AN INTERFUND LOAN BETWEEN THE GENERAL FUND 001 TO THE
ROADS/STREET CONSTRUCTION FUND 316. CARRIED.
d. Engineering and Construction Management Services, BHC — 2016 AC
Water Line Replacement
Ryan Johnstone stated the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) approved as part
of the current water system plan contains water main replacement projects
necessary to increase the reliability and efficiency of the potable water
distribution system. One of the primary ways to accomplish this is to replace old,
AC water main with new PVC or ductile iron, and to address deficiencies in
capacity (i.e. undersized pipe). Several pipe segments were included in the 2014
Water Main Replacement Project. Council approved these projects on July 22,
2014 for design by BHC, LLC. The contract was approved in the amount of
$84,369 at that time and added to on October 14, 2014 for a total design
approval of $132,710. The project was broken into three separate bid schedules
A, B, and C to allow for reduction in the construction contact should bid results
exceed the budgeted amount. Yelm Ave E was added to the CIP because it was
AC pipe, undersized (6") for the system needs of potable water circulation,
needed upgrade for fire flow, and was logical to replace while replacing the tow
adjoining pipe segments. City staff put forth a solid effort to replace the Yelm Ave
E main prior to the WSDOT overlay completed earlier this year but was
unsuccessful due to planning and scheduling challenges with WSDOT. This will
affect the construction costs associated with this pipe segment, but could remain
nominal, as a full Asphalt depth overlay will not be required. Design of the
Schedule A water main sections is currently 80% complete. If the request for
additional scope of services is approved, design will resume upon adoption of the
2016 budget (early January). Anticipated completion and out for bid in March
2016, with construction completion near June 2016. Approval to complete the
design, bid, and construction management support of the Schedule A pipe
segments will increase the design contract by $30,924. Project funding for the
remaining design and construction will be from the 404 Water Capital
Improvement Fund and is included in the 2016 Proposed Budget.
15-112 MOTION BY 3W FOSTER AUTHORIZING MAYOR HARDING TO SIGN A
CONTRACT AMENDMENT IN THE AMOUNT OF $30,924.00 WITH BHC
CONSULTANTS FOR ADDITIONAL DESIGN SERVICES FOR ASBESTOS
CEMENT (AC) WATER MAIN REPLACEMENT. CARRIED.
12/8/15
e. 2015/16 Legislative Services Contract
Noah Crocker, Finance Director explained that Kathleen Collins, of Capitol
Strategies, and Davor Gjurasic, of Gjurasic Public Affairs, have been contracted to
work for the City at various times since 2005 and are well acquainted with issues
of great importance to the City, particularly the 510 Yelm Loop project. Their
presence and advocacy of Yelm issues during legislative sessions is of significant
value and has proved beneficial to advancement of the Loop project, as well as
receiving funding for capital projects, such as the Longmire Park restrooms and
community center. This contract continues efforts toward the completion of the
510 Yelm Loop, specifically inclusion of moving funding ahead of its current
schedule. It also includes other issues considered by the Legislature and/or
voters; monitors water and reclaimed water issues; and provides assistance in
identifying funding opportunities for capital projects. Monthly summaries will be
provided as part of the contract, as well as a legislative summary at the end of
the legislative session. The 2015/16 contract state date of November 1, 2015 will
include compensation for these services are $20,000 at $4,000 per month, and
combined expenses not to exceed $2,000. Funds expended in 2015 will come
from the General Fund (001), Arterial Streets (102) and ; 2015-2016 expenses
will be budgeted from the General Fund (001), Arterial Streets (102) and Water
Fund (401) on a pro -rata share or work performed on the issues. Councilmember
Stillwell asked how often we would get feedback from the lobbyists. Mayor
Harding stated he would probably meet with them at least 2 dozen times during
the contracted time.
15-113 MOTION BY BOB ISOM TO AUTHORIZE MAYOR HARDING TO SIGN A
LEGISLATIVE SERVICES CONTRACT TO ENGAGE DAVOR GJURASIC AND
KATHLEEN COLLINS TO LOBBY ISSUES OF BENEFIT TO THE CITY OF YELM
FROM NOVEMBER 1, 2015 THROUGH MARCH 31, 2016. CARRIED.
f. Ordinance No. 1009, 2015 Year End Budget Amendment
Noah Crocker explained there are variations in both revenue and expenditure
appropriations occur throughout the budget year, creating the need for
amendments. The City of Yelm adopts the annual budget by department level for
the Current/General Fund and by fund level for all other funds. The 2015
Amendment total is $69020.00. Appropriation changes include adjustments to
balance the departments/funds for fund 109 Yelm Police Department School
Resource related to salaries and benefits. The net effect to ending cash is
($3,953.00). Councilmember Isom asked if the increase was a direct result of the
new Police contract. Noah stated it was.
15-114 MOTION BY BOB ISOM ADOPTING ORDINANCE NO. 1009 AMENDING THE
2015 BUDGET BY APPROPRIATING FUNDS FOR 2015 CONTRACT
OBLIGATIONS, TRANSFERS, AND OTHER EXPENDITURE RELATED BUDGET
ADJUSTMENTS. CARRIED.
9. Old Business —none scheduled
10. Mayor and Council Initiatives
Councilmember Baker attended the Intercity Transit Board meeting and
reported the three positions on the Citizen Action Committee have now been
filled. At the Intercity Transit Board meeting Councilmember Baker was presented
a plaque, a clock and a Proclamation in honor of his time at Intercity Transit.
Rosemont and other businesses can get discounted passes by simply applying.
12/8/15
Councilmember Isom thanked Councilmember Baker and Councilmember
Garmann for their years of service on the Council. Councilmember Isom attended
the Thurston Regional Planning Council meeting where the Thurston Climate
Action Team gave a presentation and the survey and results are on their website.
The Executive Director's evaluation went very well. The annual contract will be
coming up very soon and dues will be billed in March.
Councilmember Wood thanked Councilmember Baker and Councilmember
Garmann for their service and stated they will be missed.
Councilmember Hendrickson attended the Yelm Emergency Operations Board
meeting where they discussed Tacoma/La Grande has increased their water by
700 cubic feet going over the damn. It is up to 6,300 cubic feet per second.
Thurston County has activated their Emergency Coordination Center due to all the
rain and flooding.
Mayor Harding thanked Councilmember Baker and Councilmember Garmann for
their service and it has been a pleasure working with both of you during your
terms. Mayor Harding also thanked Councilmember Littlefield for her service. Staff
will be hosting a small reception for the outgoing Councilmember's and those
invitations will be sent out soon. Mayor Harding received a phone call yesterday
from Thurston County Commissioner Sandra Romero in regards to the HOME
Consortium Group. HOME Consortium is the advisory board that awards money
that is taken in through document preservation. The group has voted to self -
dissolve at their last meeting. They would like to transfer the authority to award
funding from HOME Consortium to a new group called the Community Initiation
Partnership (CIP). In order to be a member of this newly formed group CIP, the
county is asking for a financial commitment of one-half of one percent of our sales
tax collected to assist in funding the organization. Mayor Harding told
Commissioner Romero that he would relay the message but he does not fully
understand the authority of the group or the funding stream. Councilmember
Isom asked that this matter be brought to a future Study Session. Mayor Harding
stated Commissioner Romero wanted a commitment by Friday, December 11,
2015. Council consensus was that they could not vote on something that they did
not fully understand.
11. Executive Session - none scheduled
12. Correspondence included -
Yelm Area Chamber of Commerce December Forum & Luncheon, Tuesday,
December 8, 11:30 -fpm, Prairie Park Hotel
Councilmember Foster was unable to attend the Christmas in the Park but would
like to know how it went in the new Community Center building. Councilmember
Hendrickson wanted to recognize John Edwards for working the event all day with a
smile on his face. Mayor Harding stated there is a large participation of city staff
and school staff and the Chamber and businesses that work the event. There were
many positive comments about the Community Center. Councilmember
Hendrickson thanked Councilmember Woods and Mr. Doug's Restaurant for
donating the hot dogs.
13. ourned at 7:0 Am.
r
Attest:
RiA Ha r6 in a y o Lori Mossman, Deputy City Clerk
12/8/15